LikeThisGame
Games Like

Mafia

200263/100
FightingShooterRacingAdventure

Branching Story · Open World · Stealth

Mafia's strength lies in its commitment to a specific, highly detailed vision of 1930s gangster life. Its narrative-driven missions, punctuated by brutal shootouts and white-knuckle car chases, offer a compelling cinematic experience. The game's open world, though arguably limited by modern standards, still impresses with its attention to period-accurate vehicles, music, and atmosphere, creating a distinct sense of place that few titles have replicated.
Mafia is a 3D action crime epic set in the seedy underworld of the 1930's. Rise from the lowly but well-dressed Footsoldier, to an envied and feared Made Man in an era of mob hits, car chases, and bootlegging. Earn a reputation as a tough enforcer, daring getaway driver, and deadly hitman in your quest for respect and power within the Salieri Family.

Top 4 Alternatives to Mafia

1
Rating
Critic & community
98
Match
Recommendation strength
85%

Grand Theft Auto IV

2008 · Shooter

Like Mafia, Grand Theft Auto IV plunges you into a gritty, mature crime narrative, but shifts the setting to a modern-day New York City analogue, offering a similarly compelling story of an immigrant seeking fortune and facing moral dilemmas within the criminal underworld.

Why recommended

  • Features intense vehicular combat and on-foot gunplay, demanding precise aiming and tactical use of cover, aligning with the Action criteria.
  • The narrative often presents difficult choices with lasting consequences, adding a layer of challenging decision-making to the core gameplay.
  • Engages players with a deep, character-driven story about loyalty, betrayal, and the American Dream, echoing Mafia's strong narrative focus on organized crime.
2
Rating
Critic & community
76
Match
Recommendation strength
78%

Ghost Recon: Wildlands transports you to a vast, hostile open world, much like Mafia's sprawling city, but tasks you with dismantling a drug cartel through tactical stealth and intense gunfights, offering a similar sense of high-stakes criminal enterprise.

Why recommended

  • Emphasizes tactical third-person shooter combat, allowing players to engage in direct firefights or utilize stealth to eliminate targets, fulfilling the Action criteria.
  • Features robust cooperative Multiplayer, allowing up to four players to tackle missions together, coordinating strategies and covering each other in combat.
  • The game presents a Challenging Difficulty through its open-ended missions, requiring careful planning, reconnaissance, and execution to avoid being overwhelmed by enemy forces.
3
Rating
Critic & community
87
Match
Recommendation strength
70%

Helldivers 2 trades Mafia's grounded crime for bombastic sci-fi warfare, but delivers a similar adrenaline-pumping Action experience, where teamwork and tactical execution are paramount to overcoming overwhelming odds.

Why recommended

  • Features intense third-person shooter combat against hordes of enemies, with a strong emphasis on precise shooting, tactical positioning, and managing powerful stratagems, directly meeting the Action criteria.
  • Designed as a cooperative Multiplayer experience, where up to four players work together to complete objectives and survive, making teamwork essential for success.
  • The game is renowned for its Challenging Difficulty, requiring constant communication, strategic use of limited resources, and adaptation to dynamic mission parameters to avoid being overrun.
4
Rating
Critic & community
82
Match
Recommendation strength
68%

While a departure in setting, Death Stranding shares Mafia's emphasis on a solitary protagonist navigating a hostile world, delivering packages and connecting disparate elements, all while facing constant threats and a deeply emotional, cinematic narrative.

Why recommended

  • Core gameplay loop involves meticulous planning for traversing treacherous terrain and engaging in stealth or direct combat against various threats, fulfilling the Action criteria.
  • The game's 'strand' system encourages indirect Multiplayer interaction, where players can leave supplies and structures for others, subtly aiding each other in a shared world.
  • The demanding traversal mechanics, resource management, and encounters with BTs or MULEs provide a consistently Challenging Difficulty that requires strategic thinking and careful execution.

Explore More Games

Want Personalized Recommendations?

Tell us what you love about your favorite games and get AI-powered suggestions tailored just for you. Free and instant.

Get Custom Recommendations