LikeThisGame
Games Like

Mafia: Definitive Edition

202075/100
ShooterAdventure

Open World

This is a story-driven crime epic that lives and dies by its commitment to a singular, oppressive atmosphere. The slow-burn narrative of Tommy Angelo's rise and fall is anchored by a meticulously recreated 1930s city that feels less like a playground and more like a character in itself. You return for the weight of its moral choices and the tactile, deliberate gunplay that makes every confrontation feel consequential.

About Mafia: Definitive Edition

View Game Details
Re-made from the ground up, rise through the ranks of the Mafia during the Prohibition era of organized crime. After a run-in with the mob, cab driver Tommy Angelo is thrust into a deadly underworld. Initially uneasy about falling in with the Salieri crime family, Tommy soon finds that the rewards are too big to ignore.

Top 4 Alternatives to Mafia: Definitive Edition

1
Rating
Critic & community
79
Match
Recommendation strength
75%

Payday 2

2013 · Shooter

Fans of Mafia: Definitive Edition's organized crime themes and action-packed heists would love this cooperative shooter that emphasizes teamwork, planning, and intense firefights.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused cooperative gameplay with organized crime themes similar to Mafia
  • Multiplayer co-op for up to 4 players with challenging heist missions
  • Known for punishing difficulty requiring coordination and skill in firefights
2
Rating
Critic & community
80
Match
Recommendation strength
70%

Fans of Mafia's realistic gunplay and tactical combat will appreciate this hardcore multiplayer shooter that emphasizes realism, positioning, and punishing difficulty.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused tactical shooter with realistic combat mechanics
  • Multiplayer with cooperative and competitive modes
  • Known for challenging difficulty with low time-to-kill and realistic ballistics
3
Rating
Critic & community
79
Match
Recommendation strength
68%

While moving from organized crime to counter-terrorism, this shares Mafia's tactical action focus and delivers punishing difficulty in a multiplayer environment that rewards precision and strategy.

Why recommended

  • Action-packed tactical shooter with high-stakes combat
  • Multiplayer-focused with competitive and cooperative modes
  • Extremely challenging difficulty with one-shot kills and steep learning curve
4
Rating
Critic & community
77
Match
Recommendation strength
65%

This cooperative horror shooter captures the tense, methodical action of Mafia's combat sequences while delivering punishing difficulty that requires careful coordination and resource management.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused cooperative gameplay with tense combat scenarios
  • Multiplayer co-op for 1-4 players requiring teamwork
  • Extremely challenging difficulty with punishing mechanics and limited resources

Explore More Games

Want Personalized Recommendations?

Tell us what you love about your favorite games and get AI-powered suggestions tailored just for you. Free and instant.

Get Custom Recommendations