LikeThisGame
Mafia: Definitive Edition
Games Like

Mafia: Definitive Edition

202075/100
ShooterAdventure

Open World

This is a story-driven crime epic that lives and dies by its commitment to a singular, oppressive atmosphere. The slow-burn narrative of Tommy Angelo's rise and fall is anchored by a meticulously recreated 1930s city that feels less like a playground and more like a character in itself. You return for the weight of its moral choices and the tactile, deliberate gunplay that makes every confrontation feel consequential.

About Mafia: Definitive Edition

Details
The city of Lost Heaven got hit hard by The Great Depression, and the advent of Prohibition in America means lucrative business opportunities for mobsters. The Salieri and Morello crime families vie for control over Lost Heaven, even as its few honest policemen scramble to maintain order. Thomas Angelo's humble life as a hard-working taxi driver is forever changed after a fateful run-in with the Italian Mafia.

Top 4 Alternatives to Mafia: Definitive Edition

1
Rating
Critic & community
79
Match
Recommendation strength
75%

Payday 2

2013 · Shooter

Fans of Mafia: Definitive Edition's organized crime themes and action-packed heists would love this cooperative shooter that emphasizes teamwork, planning, and intense firefights.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused cooperative gameplay with organized crime themes similar to Mafia
  • Multiplayer co-op for up to 4 players with challenging heist missions
  • Known for punishing difficulty requiring coordination and skill in firefights
2
Rating
Critic & community
80
Match
Recommendation strength
70%

Fans of Mafia's realistic gunplay and tactical combat will appreciate this hardcore multiplayer shooter that emphasizes realism, positioning, and punishing difficulty.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused tactical shooter with realistic combat mechanics
  • Multiplayer with cooperative and competitive modes
  • Known for challenging difficulty with low time-to-kill and realistic ballistics
3
Rating
Critic & community
79
Match
Recommendation strength
68%

While moving from organized crime to counter-terrorism, this shares Mafia's tactical action focus and delivers punishing difficulty in a multiplayer environment that rewards precision and strategy.

Why recommended

  • Action-packed tactical shooter with high-stakes combat
  • Multiplayer-focused with competitive and cooperative modes
  • Extremely challenging difficulty with one-shot kills and steep learning curve
4
Rating
Critic & community
77
Match
Recommendation strength
65%

This cooperative horror shooter captures the tense, methodical action of Mafia's combat sequences while delivering punishing difficulty that requires careful coordination and resource management.

Why recommended

  • Action-focused cooperative gameplay with tense combat scenarios
  • Multiplayer co-op for 1-4 players requiring teamwork
  • Extremely challenging difficulty with punishing mechanics and limited resources

Explore Mafia: Definitive Edition in detail

Screenshots, prices, playtime, streams and more

View Page →

Want something more specific?

Select criteria to get personalized recommendations

Select at least 1

Explore More Games