LikeThisGame
Games Like

Mafia II

201073/100
ShooterRacingAdventure

Branching Story · Fantasy · Historical · Open World · Sandbox · Stealth

Mafia II's narrative ambition is its most defining trait, a sprawling crime saga set against the backdrop of a meticulously crafted 1940s and 50s America. The game's strength lies in its cinematic presentation; lengthy cutscenes and a strong focus on character development deliver a story that feels more like an interactive gangster film. While its open-world activities are somewhat basic, the sheer quality of the narrative and the immersion it creates are what keeps players returning.

About Mafia II

View Game Details
The storyline for Mafia II is a gritty drama and chronicles the rise of Vito Scaletta, the son of Sicilian immigrants. As the game progresses, Vito joins the Falcone crime family and becomes "a made man" along with his best friend Joe Barbaro.

Top 5 Alternatives to Mafia II

1
Rating
Critic & community
97
Match
Recommendation strength
88%

Grand Theft Auto V

2013 · Action

Fans of Mafia II's immersive open-world crime narrative and engaging third-person action will find a modern, expansive take on the genre in Grand Theft Auto V, complete with a compelling story and dynamic multiplayer.

Why recommended

  • Features an expansive open-world crime sandbox with a gripping, character-driven narrative.
  • Core gameplay centers on intense third-person shooting, high-speed driving, and diverse action sequences.
  • Includes a massive and evolving multiplayer ecosystem in Grand Theft Auto Online, alongside its acclaimed single-player campaign.
2
Rating
Critic & community
67
Match
Recommendation strength
82%

If you enjoyed Mafia II's historical organized crime setting and the feeling of building a criminal empire, The Godfather II offers a similar deep dive into mob life with strategic elements and robust third-person action.

Why recommended

  • Immerses players in a historical organized crime setting, allowing them to rise through the ranks of a crime family.
  • Features third-person action gameplay with shooting, melee combat, and strategic elements for taking over rackets.
  • Includes competitive multiplayer modes where players manage crews and engage in gang warfare.
3
Rating
Critic & community
82
Match
Recommendation strength
78%

For those who appreciate Mafia II's open-world urban exploration and engaging narrative, Watch Dogs 2 provides a contemporary twist with hacking mechanics, a vibrant city, and seamless online interactions.

Why recommended

  • Offers an expansive open-world urban environment to explore, filled with diverse activities and a compelling narrative.
  • Core gameplay combines third-person shooting, driving, and unique hacking abilities for dynamic action.
  • Features seamless co-op and competitive multiplayer modes integrated directly into the open-world experience.
4
Rating
Critic & community
93
Match
Recommendation strength
75%

While different in theme, fans of Mafia II's mature, gritty storytelling and third-person action will appreciate Metal Gear Solid V's expansive open-world design, tactical gameplay, and deep narrative.

Why recommended

  • Delivers a sprawling, critically acclaimed single-player narrative campaign with mature themes and complex characters.
  • Core gameplay involves tactical stealth, third-person shooting, and strategic resource management in an open-world setting.
  • Includes a dedicated online mode, Metal Gear Online 3, offering competitive team-based multiplayer combat.
5
Rating
Critic & community
84
Match
Recommendation strength
72%

If you enjoyed the open-world crime elements and vehicular action of Mafia II but crave a more over-the-top and humorous experience, Saints Row: The Third delivers explosive action and a full co-op campaign.

Why recommended

  • Features a full, humorous single-player story campaign centered on building a criminal empire in an open city.
  • Core gameplay is action-packed, involving over-the-top combat, vehicle stunts, and explosive set pieces.
  • Allows the entire single-player campaign to be played cooperatively, providing a meaningful multiplayer experience.

Explore More Games

Want Personalized Recommendations?

Tell us what you love about your favorite games and get AI-powered suggestions tailored just for you. Free and instant.

Get Custom Recommendations