LikeThisGame
Mafia II
Games Like

Mafia II

201073/100
ShooterRacingAdventure

Branching Story · Fantasy · Historical · Open World · Sandbox · Stealth

Mafia II delivers a compelling open-world crime drama, trading in the genre's usual sandbox antics for a tightly-scripted narrative. The game's strength lies in its meticulously crafted setting, a loving recreation of 1940s and 50s America, and the surprisingly grounded, character-driven story of a mobster's rise and fall. Its cover-based shooting and driving mechanics, while functional, serve to immerse the player in a world where every decision carries weight, and loyalty is a dangerous currency.
The storyline for Mafia II is a gritty drama and chronicles the rise of Vito Scaletta, the son of Sicilian immigrants. As the game progresses, Vito joins the Falcone crime family and becomes "a made man" along with his best friend Joe Barbaro.

Top 4 Alternatives to Mafia II

1
Rating
Critic & community
96
Match
Recommendation strength
91%

Grand Theft Auto V

2013 · Shooter

Like Mafia II, this game plunges you into a sprawling criminal underworld, but with a modern twist and three interwoven protagonists, offering a similar blend of high-stakes heists, intense shootouts, and open-world freedom.

Why recommended

  • Features a robust single-player campaign focused on criminal activities, car chases, and gunfights, directly aligning with Mafia II's core gameplay loop.
  • Criteria — Offers both a deep Singleplayer narrative experience and an expansive Multiplayer component (GTA Online) for cooperative and competitive play.
  • The open-world design allows for extensive exploration and emergent gameplay, providing a similar sense of freedom and scale as Mafia II's Empire Bay.
2
Rating
Critic & community
94
Match
Recommendation strength
85%

Step into the neon-soaked 1980s, where the criminal underworld thrives with a style all its own, offering the same blend of open-world exploration, narrative-driven crime, and intense action that defined Mafia II.

Why recommended

  • Provides a compelling single-player narrative centered around a rising figure in the criminal underworld, featuring themes of loyalty, betrayal, and power similar to Mafia II.
  • Criteria — A classic Singleplayer open-world experience that immerses players in a vibrant, crime-filled city, fulfilling the 'Singleplayer' and 'Action' criteria.
  • Offers a large, explorable open world with diverse missions involving driving, shooting, and strategic planning, echoing the sandbox freedom and mission variety of Mafia II.
3
Rating
Critic & community
83
Match
Recommendation strength
78%

While Mafia II puts you in the shoes of a gangster, L.A. Noire places you on the other side of the law, but both games excel at delivering a gripping narrative set in a meticulously recreated historical period, full of intrigue and impactful choices.

Why recommended

  • Set in a richly detailed post-WWII Los Angeles, offering a strong sense of historical immersion and atmosphere akin to Mafia II's 1940s-50s setting.
  • Criteria — Primarily a Singleplayer experience with a strong emphasis on narrative progression and character development, fulfilling the 'Singleplayer' criteria.
  • Features action sequences, including gunfights and car chases, integrated into a story-driven adventure, providing similar adrenaline-pumping moments as Mafia II.
4
Rating
Critic & community
82
Match
Recommendation strength
70%

Shift from the gritty 1940s to a vibrant, modern-day San Francisco, but retain the thrill of operating outside the law, using hacking as your weapon instead of tommy guns, in a similarly expansive open world.

Why recommended

  • Features an open-world environment ripe for exploration and emergent gameplay, allowing players to approach missions with freedom, reminiscent of Mafia II's sandbox elements.
  • Criteria — Offers a compelling Singleplayer campaign focused on action and adventure, alongside cooperative Multiplayer options for specific missions and free-roam.
  • Engages players in various action-oriented missions, including stealth, driving, and combat, delivering a similar pace and excitement to Mafia II's criminal escapades.

Explore Mafia II in detail

Screenshots, prices, playtime, streams and more

View Page →

Want something more specific?

Select criteria to get personalized recommendations

Select at least 1

Explore More Games