LikeThisGame
Mafia II
Games Like

Mafia II

201073/100
ShooterRacingAdventure

Branching Story · Fantasy · Historical · Open World · Sandbox · Stealth

Mafia II delivers a compelling open-world crime drama, trading in the genre's usual sandbox antics for a tightly-scripted narrative. The game's strength lies in its meticulously crafted setting, a loving recreation of 1940s and 50s America, and the surprisingly grounded, character-driven story of a mobster's rise and fall. Its cover-based shooting and driving mechanics, while functional, serve to immerse the player in a world where every decision carries weight, and loyalty is a dangerous currency.
Mafia II is a third-person action-adventure game set in the fictional American city of Empire Bay between 1945 and 1951. Players control Vito Scaletta through a story-driven campaign involving organized crime, navigating an open world on foot or by vehicle. Gameplay combines shooting, driving, and limited melee combat, with a wanted system that escalates law enforcement response based on criminal activity. The game features era-appropriate vehicles, licensed period music across multiple radio stations, and a cover-based combat system.

Top 4 Alternatives to Mafia II

1
Rating
Critic & community
96
Match
Recommendation strength
91%

Grand Theft Auto V

2013 · Shooter

Like Mafia II, this game plunges you into a sprawling criminal underworld, but with a modern twist and three interwoven protagonists, offering a similar blend of high-stakes heists, intense shootouts, and open-world freedom.

Why recommended

  • Features a robust single-player campaign focused on criminal activities, car chases, and gunfights, directly aligning with Mafia II's core gameplay loop.
  • Criteria — Offers both a deep Singleplayer narrative experience and an expansive Multiplayer component (GTA Online) for cooperative and competitive play.
  • The open-world design allows for extensive exploration and emergent gameplay, providing a similar sense of freedom and scale as Mafia II's Empire Bay.
2
Rating
Critic & community
94
Match
Recommendation strength
85%

Step into the neon-soaked 1980s, where the criminal underworld thrives with a style all its own, offering the same blend of open-world exploration, narrative-driven crime, and intense action that defined Mafia II.

Why recommended

  • Provides a compelling single-player narrative centered around a rising figure in the criminal underworld, featuring themes of loyalty, betrayal, and power similar to Mafia II.
  • Criteria — A classic Singleplayer open-world experience that immerses players in a vibrant, crime-filled city, fulfilling the 'Singleplayer' and 'Action' criteria.
  • Offers a large, explorable open world with diverse missions involving driving, shooting, and strategic planning, echoing the sandbox freedom and mission variety of Mafia II.
3
Rating
Critic & community
83
Match
Recommendation strength
78%

While Mafia II puts you in the shoes of a gangster, L.A. Noire places you on the other side of the law, but both games excel at delivering a gripping narrative set in a meticulously recreated historical period, full of intrigue and impactful choices.

Why recommended

  • Set in a richly detailed post-WWII Los Angeles, offering a strong sense of historical immersion and atmosphere akin to Mafia II's 1940s-50s setting.
  • Criteria — Primarily a Singleplayer experience with a strong emphasis on narrative progression and character development, fulfilling the 'Singleplayer' criteria.
  • Features action sequences, including gunfights and car chases, integrated into a story-driven adventure, providing similar adrenaline-pumping moments as Mafia II.
4
Rating
Critic & community
82
Match
Recommendation strength
70%

Shift from the gritty 1940s to a vibrant, modern-day San Francisco, but retain the thrill of operating outside the law, using hacking as your weapon instead of tommy guns, in a similarly expansive open world.

Why recommended

  • Features an open-world environment ripe for exploration and emergent gameplay, allowing players to approach missions with freedom, reminiscent of Mafia II's sandbox elements.
  • Criteria — Offers a compelling Singleplayer campaign focused on action and adventure, alongside cooperative Multiplayer options for specific missions and free-roam.
  • Engages players in various action-oriented missions, including stealth, driving, and combat, delivering a similar pace and excitement to Mafia II's criminal escapades.

Explore Mafia II in detail

Screenshots, prices, playtime, streams and more

View Page →
Personal builder

Personalize this list

Starts with Mafia II; choose criteria or wildcard mode in the builder.

Get personalized recommendations
Like these recommendations?Support the projectOne-time support via Patreon. No subscription required.

Explore More Games